Tōgō Murano Dialogues: Session 1, pp.28–33

Graduation and Heading for the Freedom of Osaka
Hasegawa: Judging by the number of questions we received, many people would like to know why you chose to begin your career in Osaka, and why you were based there for all of your professional life. Perhaps we could begin there?
Murano: Yes, let’s start with some facts and set other matters aside for a moment. I was born in Karatsu in Kyushu and grew up in Yahata. I graduated from Waseda University in 1918. In those days, job opportunities were not as plentiful as they are today. My mentor, Professor Koichi Sato, was concerned about my future and went to great lengths to secure a position for me in the design department of Obayashi Corporation’s Tokyo branch. The terms were quite favorable, I might add. If I had joined Obayashi, I don’t think I would have lasted very long. (Laughs)
Instead, Setsu Watanabe (渡邊節1) had established his own architectural firm in Osaka and one day he visited the university to select a graduate to work for him. I’m not sure if I was conspicuous, or if one of my professors recommended me, but he told the university, “I want Murano to work for me.” When they told him, “He’s already set to join the Tokyo branch of Obayashi,” he insisted, “I’ll speak to Obayashi myself – just send him to me.” In short, I was scouted. Furthermore, the offer in Osaka came with even better terms, and so I began working for Watanabe. My parents were delighted with me moving to Osaka because, back then, the way people from Kyushu perceived Tokyo and Osaka was quite different. Tokyo was seen as a very distant place and the temperament entirely different. The people of Osaka were seen as down-to-earth in stark contrast to Tokyo and its people, both seen as distant.

(1884-1967)


Former Osaka Merchant Shipping Kobe Branch 1922





In many ways, Tokyo would have been a difficult place for me to feel at home in. Firstly, as the eldest son, I knew my parents would be very happy to have me living closer by. Another reason I chose Osaka was that, even back then, the city offered a certain degree of freedom. In Tokyo at the time there, a more rigid and formulaic type of architecture was dominant. In Osaka, however, a few examples of a freer and more unconventional architecture had already begun to appear and, from the standpoint of architecture, I found these more compelling, and that Osaka was the better place to be. This was the immediate motivation for my move.
Once I began living there, helped in part by the fact that some of my friends were based in the Semba district, I came to truly appreciate the city’s merits.
I spent thirteen years learning at Watanabe-sensei’s firm and, with his blessing, after having completed the design for this very building – the Cotton Industry Club as my final project, I set out to establish my own practice. I can tell you more about the virtues of Osaka another time, when the topic comes up.
I was particularly drawn to the down-to-earth, common-man spirit of Osaka. I later realized that in Tokyo, there is a tendency to value people only if they possess certain formal credentials or prestigious accolades and that it was in a sense, a highly formalistic culture. By contrast, in Osaka, by contrast, it is possible to strike out on your own if you have genuine ability and can even, to put it more broadly, build a fortune. The history of Osaka’s was once centered on the textile industry and this building, the Cotton Industry Club, is a testament to that era. Osaka retains a spirit that encourages individuals to create their own path through hard work. It is a meritocracy: if you have the skill and, crucially, the integrity to go with it, then you can make your way. That is perhaps one of the primary reasons I was drawn to Osaka. Furthermore, the broader cultural landscape that includes Kyoto was also a significant factor in my decision to put down roots here.
Style-based architecture
Hasegawa: So, during your time at Watanabe’s firm, you had almost no opportunity to work on what we would now call “modern” architecture?
Murano: That’s correct.
Hasegawa: I’m not sure if this is the right term, but… you mean “stylish”2 architecture?
Murano: Yes. To return to the beginning, back in my school days, I was a problem student because whenever we were given an assignment on architectural styles, I wouldn’t follow the prescribed style. Instead, I’d focus entirely on the Secessionist movement, that movement for artistic reform movement which emerged in Germany and Austria around the turn of the 20th century. My grades were terrible and I was considered completely unmanageable. Perhaps unmanageable isn’t quite the right word… In any case, I never once produced a design based on traditional architectural styles. Even when an assignment called for one, I simply wouldn’t3 do it. It’s a wonder I managed to graduate at all! (Laughs)
Murano: When I first joined Watanabe’s firm, it was the era of what we call “eclecticism.” People were eager for Western-style architecture of the kind they had seen firsthand by traveling to Europe or America. In Japan, however, the economic and social conditions had already undergone modernization, and these Western architectural styles were essentially being superimposed onto the existing reality and this is how “eclectic” architecture emerged. At Watanabe’s, I was tasked with creating these eclectic and style-based designs and this is something I had never had to do during my time at school. To be perfectly honest, I made quite a few unreasonable demands when I first joined. Though they had brought me on board but the situation was more like, “Good heavens, what kind of person have we ended up with?” The first three years were a real struggle.
I struggled immensely and constantly wondered when I should leave. Then, as it happened, there was a limited competition between different architectural firms and my design was submitted on behalf of our office and won. This was the turning point. Watanabe-sensei realized that it was a mistake to immediately assign a fresh graduate tasks such as drafting full-scale construction details. From that moment on, my fortunes began to change. Watanabe started assigning me one project after another in these various Western styles that we now call “eclectic” architecture. At that time, Watanabe said to me, “Murano, I want you to create designs that sell.” I found that to be a wonderful, straightforward remark that was so characteristic of Watanabe and, in a way, so characteristic of Osaka, too. He was suggesting that one should focus on creating designs that sell, rather than getting bogged down in abstract artistic theory.
In truth, if you want to run a firm successfully and ensure that your clients are satisfied, then this is exactly the approach you must take. And yet, it’s not as if Watanabe-sensei was a dogmatic proponent of these styles himself. He saw it as simply a necessity for managing the firm and meeting the wishes of his clients. “Create designs that sell4” was the mandate. From a practical standpoint and as someone running a firm, I believe that approach was only natural. This is how I see it now, looking back.






Nevertheless, as I continued to work in this manner, I began to become increasingly fascinated with this thing called “stylistic architecture” and the Cotton Industry Club5 which is the final project I worked on at the Watanabe office is testament to this. This is why I have such a personal interest in this building we’re in now. When I speak or write about “stylistic architecture,” I am not referring merely to “form.” Rather, it is about lines, planes, shadows, and the combination of materials and other subtle elements in which the essence of stylistic architecture lies. Understanding this, I believe, is the most crucial aspect of engaging with such architecture. It is not the form itself, but rather the interplay of lines, planes, shadows, and materials that constitutes its fundamental core. This is why, even after I established my own practice, I was able to create works with complete freedom, unconstrained by rigid adherence to any specific “style.” The lessons I learned during that period had a profound influence on me. I believe this principle holds true for architecture in general. I don’t necessarily intend to specifically discuss “modern architecture” but I believe this concept is universally applicable. What I have learned about stylistic architecture is that it transcends the labels of specific styles. It is something that exists on a level above “style” itself.
Hmm. So we have some fundamental attributes of architecture (such as lines, planes, shadows, and the combination of materials and other elements) working together to create something that’s beyond style but that we’ll call “stylistic” for want of a better word. Murano is dismantling the stuff of architecture into what he sees are its constituent attributes in the sense of them all being things that architects can manipulate. I agree with this as an approach. Murano’s attributes are all tangible ones that everyone can see and, at least so far, not associations that others apply and, because of this, would be universally applicable. Murano is saying these thoughts were prompted sometime after 1918 and was able to consider them and begin to apply them sometime around 1930. He was certainly thinking about them in 1919 when he put his thoughts down in the book Staying Above Style [Yoshiki no Ueniare, 様式の上にあれ ]. He was 28, had only just begun working for Watanabe and was to stay there another 14 years. It’s interesting that Murano mentions shadows. Jun’ichirō Tanizaki’s In Praise of Shadows (In’ei Raisan, 陰翳礼讃) was published in 1933 
• • •
- 11/10/2016: The 心 of a Person Who Makes Architecture
- 18/10/2026: Tōgō Murano Dialogues: Session 1, pp.9–21
- 25/10/2026: Tōgō Murano Dialogues: Session 1, pp.21–28
- More on Setsu Watanabe. https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/渡辺節 ↩︎
- Tricky. The Japanese is a transliteration of the word “stylish” but I think what Hasegawa means is something we might call “stylistic”. ↩︎
- The Japanese here is 問題が出てもやらない。”wouldn’t” is correct for やらない [yaranai]. ↩︎
- “Create designs that sell!” This is interesting. Not for a second did I think this meant “Make them low cost!” Creating designs that sell means creating designs that clients want to pay for, because of prestige, benefit of their customers or users, or whatever) and this is something very different. What makes Murano different is that his buildings seem to always be what they are yet also have some sort of appeal beyond that. It’s as if he is continuing to answer his own question of what lies beyond style. ↩︎
- Mainichi Shimbun article from which most of the above images were taken. https://mainichi.jp/english/graphs/20230817/hpe/00m/0et/001000g/20230817hpe00m0et001000q ↩︎

“Fit For Purpose”

“Building Nature”

“It’s Not Rocket Science #10: Integrated Sanitation and Nutrition“

