Category Archives: Architecture Misfits

people whose contribution to better performing buildings has not been fully appreciated

Architecture Misfit #29: Fernand Pouillon

fernand-pouillon

Fernand Pouillon
1912 ‚Äď 1986

1912
Born May 14, in Cancon, France.

ūüéā

1934
Palais Albert 1er, (30 apartments, 2 commercial units), avenue Albert 1er, Aix-en-Provence, France, in collaboration with Henri Enjouvin.

Pouillon was 22.

1935
Palais Victor Hugo (28 apartments), avenue Victor Hugo, Aix-en-Provence, France

1936
Groupe Corderie 25 (40 apartments), 27 avenue de la Corse, Marseille, France

The fernandpouillon.com website lists the creation or extension of “co-operative cells” [caves coop√®ratives”]¬†around this time, in the towns of Rosi√®res, Lussas, Vinezac, Vogue, Lablach√®re, Senas, Graveson, Maillane, Eygali√®res, Mallemort, Saint-Andiol,¬†Ch√Ęteauneuf de Gadagne, Le Thor, La Tour d’Aygues, and Sablet. All were formed in¬†association with Pouillon’s former mentor Henri Enjouvin. I imagine these to be something like¬†architects of record on-call, and with some fee arrangement already in place for fast turnaround. It would have to be because, as you will see, the amount of work attributed to Pouillon is phenomenal. Pouillon was beyond¬†prolific, he¬†had a compulsion to design buildings and get them built.

1938
Mondovi Building (18 apartments), rue de Mondovi, Marseille, France


Villa for Doctor Bernard, quartier Saint-Julien Villa de M. Magallon, avenue Flotte, Marseille, France
Villa for M. Teissier, quartier Saint-Barnabé Villa de M. Terracole, au Roucas Blanc, Marseille, France
Villa for M. Falconetti, Cabriès, France

1939
Group¬†“R√©sidence” quai de Rive-Neuve (36 apartments),¬†Marseille, France

1940
A group of 70 apartments, Avignon, France

1942 was the end of Vichy Government rule in Algeria and the end of¬†Le Corbusier’s speculative Plan Obus for Algiers. It was also the year Pouillon, now 30, became a registered architect. It had not been necessary to be one in order to build in

1943
Restoration of private mansion of M. Columeau, bd du Redon Immeuble 38 rue Longue des Capucins, Marseille, France

1944 was the liberation of France and the dissolution of the Vichy government.

1945
“Dames de France”, transformation of a store into offices for the American base
Grand Arénas, provisional accommodation for prisoners, deportees and refugees
Gendarmerie Augusto, Marseille, France

1946
The Regional Center for Physical Education and Sport, CREPS, chemin du Guiraudet Gardanne, Aix-en-Provence, France
Casablanca Garden City in Biver, 21 dwellings, Aix-en-Provence, France

1947
Deux √©coles d√©clar√©es dans les “M√©moires d’un architecte”,¬†Aix-en-Provence, France
Hotel in Cap Manuel, Dakar, Senegal
Stade municipal, avenue des Ecoles Militaires, Aix-en-Provence, France

Pouillon’s¬†1947 Aix-en-Provence City Stadium¬†is often presented as the project in which his¬†personal “style” began to emerge¬†but (in perfect illustration of how words convert buildings into architecture) this¬†turns out to be nothing more than perfectly normal things¬†that everybody should be doing, like updating traditional construction processes and using several different materials so each does what they do¬†best.

stadium 1946-50.jpeg

1948
Nestlé Factory, chocolate and soluble coffee factory, offices, common services and employee housing, Saint-Menet, France
Restoration of the Villa of Doctor Latil, Aix-en-Provence, France
Station sanitaire maritime, Avenue Vaudoyer, Marseille, France

0008

1949
Police Building, 2 rue Antoine Becker, Marseille, France
Canebière Building, boulevard de la Canebière, apartments, offices, retail units, Marseille, France
La Tourette, Protis Square, 260 dwellings, shops garages, Marseille, France 

The civic projects increased in scale and importance, leading to the¬†1948-1953 La Tourette housing complex in Marseille, just behind¬†the Old Port.¬†There’s a glowing description of La Tourette¬†here, along¬†with¬†many fine photographs of it.

With La Tourette project, Pouillon refined his¬†system of co-ordinating all the elements of a project ‚Äď a system that came to be known as The Pouillon System.¬†Details are sketchy, but it¬†included artists and craftsmen such as cabinetmakers, locksmiths and stonecutters and the invention/use¬†of construction processes intended to reduce the cost of material and labour.¬†One of these was pierre banch√©e in which stone tiles are used¬†as permanent shuttering.

LE+GENIE+DE+POUILLON+-+ECONOMIE+ET+QUALITE

Other innovations included a method of providing better soundproofing between apartments. A legend to the section above might be able to tell us more about this. In 1955, Pouillon created the CNL, the Comptoir National du Logement, which was a commercial and legal structure that would allow him to design thousands of housing units in Paris and to build them as a developer.

1950
Reconstruction of the Sablettes, seaside resort, 150 apartments, shops, a hotel, La Seyne-sur-Mer, France
Carrières de Fontvieille, La Seyne-sur-Mer, France
Offices, Garden Dwellings, Atelier, La Seyne-sur-Mer, France
Atelier for the painter, Marchutz, Aix-en-Provence, France
Villa for the mayor of d’Aix-en-Provence, Henri Mouret, Aix-en-Provence, France
H√ītel d’Espagnet, Cours Mirabeau, Headquarters of the University Rectorate plus official housing, Aix-en-Provence, France
Restoration of a listed monument, Aix-en-Provence, France
Saint-Charles University Library, Marseille, France
Library of the Faculty of Sciences, Centre for Administrative Studies, Marseille, France

1951
Building rue Méry, Reconstruction of the Vieux-Port quarter, housing, shops and bars, Marseille, France
Outer areas of the Old Port district, monument surroundings, roads and public spaces, Marseille, France
Shopping Cart District Urban Redevelopment, Marseille, France
Two hundred apartments, 1-6 room apartments for rent, Aix-en-Provence, France
Reconstruction of the Old Port, seafront 1200 m, 350 apartments and shops, Marseille, France

1952
Faculty of Law, resumption of the works for completion of University Library, Aix-en-Provence, France

Villa La Brillanne, residence of the family of Fernand Pouillon, Aix-en-Provence, France
Lycée Colbert, commercial and industrial learning center, Marseille, France

1953
Atelier for the painter André Masson, Aix-en-Provence, France

Administrative City, architectural and urban development program, Avignon, France
Terminal, offices, technical block, control tower, Cassis, Marignane, France
Villa Barthélemy and Villa X., seafront villas, Algiers, Algeria
Diar El Mahçoul, 1800 apartments, Algiers, Algeria

This last was Pouillon’s first project in Algeirs and the project he was invited there for. The hillside site required 100,000 of terracing and huge retaining walls. A main road divided the French side and Algerian side. Two thirds of the 1,454 housing units were on the French side of the road with views of the sea (and huge retaining walls).

The other third were on the Algerian side facing the valley and had small courtyards. We may think this discriminatory but we forget that “view” is a cultural invention (whereas houses in a Mediterranean fishing village, for example, might have a view of the sea for reasons connected with weather and fish). Another such difference showed in sanitation facilities and, again, we can’t say if this is cultural prejudice or cultural preference.

1953 (cont’d)
Diar Es Saada, 800 lodgings, Algiers, Algeria

Villa des Arcades, restaurant, and development of a swimming pool, residence and agency of F. Alger, Algerie
Residential building, regularization of the extension of the course Jean Jaurès in front of the administrative city, Avignon, France

1954
Diar El Mahçoul, Saint-Jean-Baptiste church Climat of France, 3500 dwellings, Algiers, Algiers

Pouillon’s 1954-1957 Climat de France project for Algiers has a touch of what two decades later would be called Post-Modern Classicism. We look at it and see Rossi, unfairly.

The Mayor of Algiers believed a properly housed population made for a happy population and Pouillon obliged by combining the social aspirations of Modernism giving residents something larger to feel a part of, and the proto Post-Modern idea of giving residents something grander to live up to.

Diar Es Saada, girls ‘and boys’ schools, Algiers, Algierie
El Karma, Valmy (near Oran), Agierie
City of 800 houses, Algiers, Algierie
Cité Lescure, Designed for a colleague, Oran, Algiers
Military city for 8000 inhabitants, Magharé, Iran
Military city for 8000 inhabitants, Shahabad, Iran
Iranian Empire Headquarters, Tehran, Iran
Geographical Institute, Tehran, Iran
Railway station, Machad, Iran

This was a project in collaboration with the Iranian architect,¬†Heydar Ghia√Į-Chamlou.

Railway station, Tabriz, Iran

As was this.

1955
Cité universitaire les Gazelles, 564 avenue Gaston Berger, 500 beds, Aix-en-Provence, France

La Montagnette social housing, rue Maurice Barrès, Vignon, France
Cité La Croix des Oiseaux, about 800 social housing units with much prefabrication, rue de la Croix des Oiseaux, Avignon, France
Villa for Admiral Jubelin, Sanary, France

1956
Development of the Old Port district, partially completed. Reconstruction of several Old Port buildings, reconstruction, Bastia, France

1957
Charzola Building, 58 rue Emile Zola, 93 dwellings, Paris, France

47 avenue de Friedland, apartment for Fernand Pouillon, Paris, France
Victor Hugo Residences, avenue Jean Lolive, 282 apartments and retail units, Pantin, France

Chalet, Val d’Isere, France
Municipal stadium, rue des Ecoles Militaires, awning above the stands (destroyed in the eighties), Aix-en-Provence, France
Résidence le Parc, 2,635 lodgings, shopping centers, Meudon-la-Forêt, France

Pouillon and the CNL’s first major successes were apartment developments of three hundred units in Pantin (1957) and five hundred units in Montrouge (1958). Despite the stone and marbile finishes, the apartments were affordable on a 25-year plan.

1958
Private apartment, Boulevard Suchet, Paris, France
Le Point du Jour, 2260 logements et équipements, Boulogne-Billancourt, France
Peugeot-quai de Passy, projet d’extension du Point du Jour, Boulogne-Billancourt, France
Résidence du Stade Buffalo, 466 logements et commerces, Montrouge, France

1959
H√ītel des Ursins, √ģle de la Cit√©, r√©sidence de F. Pouillon Appartement de M. Junot I√©na, Paris, France
Résidence Jules Ferry, 60 logements et garages au rez-de-chaussée, Montrouge, France
Résidence le Parc, 2,635 lodgings, shopping centers, Meudon-la-Forêt, France

Pouillon was to make himself many enemies when the 2,635 apartments of the Résidence du Parc in Meudon-la-Forêt (1959) came online at less than market prices.

1960
Résidence du Quai, 135 apartments and shopping mall, Boulogne-Billancourt, France
H√ītel-restaurant Baumani√®re, la Cabro d’Or, Les Baux de Provence, France

1961
Hotel, Puerto-Rico

Pouillon’s unorthodox corporate arrangements encouraged financial impropriety and the CNL was unable to pay its contractors in 1959 and was wound up in 1961 and Pouillon charged, arrested, de-registered and jailed. Eighteen months later he escaped but ten months later gave himself up, only to be sentenced to another four years. This was later reduced to three and he was released in February 1964. Charges of breaching the laws of¬†companies, of breaches of trust, fraud and concealment were dismissed but charges of the abuse of social assets, false declaration of release of shares and false notarial declaration remained. During his imprisonment, we was to write Les Pierres Sauvages published in 1964, and Memoirs of an Architect, published 1968.

1962
Domaine de Lanruen (detached houses), partially realized, construction site not monitored, Erquy, France

1964
Masterplan for the new town of Créteil, Créteil, France
La Vallée Moussue, restoration of a house, Saint-Léger-en-Yvelines, France.

1965
H√ītel du Port, for the company¬†Bancaire, Saint-Jean-Cap-Ferrat, France

 

The masterplan was to be Pouillon’s first major job after jail and, perhaps because of this, he received death threats urging him not to work in France. Jacques Chevallier suggested Pouiloon return to Algeria and he did.¬†For the next twenty years Pouillon was to design hotels to improve the tourism infrastructure of Algeria, as well as many¬†civic and educational buildings. His greatest¬†regret was being¬†being asked to design mass housing again, either in France or in Algeria.

1966
Algerian coastal tourism development plan (partially realized), Algiers, Algeria
Villa des Arcades, restoration and extension, Algiers, Algeria
Diar El Mahçoul, transformation of the church into a mosque, Algiers, Algeria
Hotel Le Ca√ģd, 400 beds, Bou Saada, Algeria
Hotel Marhaba, 300 beds, Laghouat, Algeria
Hotel El Minzah, 300 beds, Moretti, Algeria
Spa and hotel with 200 beds, Saida, Algeria

1967
Pavillon de la Foire d’Alger
, Algiers, Algeria
The Calle (El Kala), Algiers, Algeria
Hotel El Manar, 300 beds, Algiers, Algeria
Tourist complex, 3,000 beds, Moretti, Algeria
Hotel El Mountazah (Ksar du Rocher), 300 beds, Sera√Įdi, Algeria
Tourist complex, 4,000 beds, Zeralda, Algeria

1968
Restaurant “Maxim’s, air conditioning and facilities, Paris, France
Caravanserai of 150 beds, Ain Sefr, Algeria
Hotel Plaza, 500 beds, Annaba, Algeria
Caravanserai the Rym, 150 beds, Beni-Abbes, Algeria
Hotel with 300 beds, Biskra, Algeria
Hotel school for 1,600 students, Biskra, Algeria
Caravanserai El Boustan, 200 beds Saharan dwellings (detached houses), Biskra, Algeria
Saharan homes (detached houses), Biskra, Algeria
New market and renovation of old market, cinema, theater, 15,000 m2, Biskra, Algeria
Abattoirs, Biskra, Gharda√Įa, Algerie
Saharan homes (detached houses), Laghouat, Algeria
Caravanserai El Mehri, 200 beds, Ouargla, Algeria
Prefecture of the Oasis and Administrative City, 15 000 m2 Saharan dwellings (detached houses), Ouargla, Algeria
Tourist complex, 4,000 beds El Riadh Hotel, Sidi Ferruch, Algeria


Tourist complex, shopping center H√ītel les Hammadites, 350 beds, Tichy, Algerie
Caravanserai El Gourara, 150 beds, Timimoun, Algeria


Tourist complex, 2,000 beds, Tipasa Beach, Algeria


Tourist complex, 2,500 beds Arrangement of the harbor, village and barbecue, Tipasa Club, Algeria
Slaughterhouses, Touggourt, Algerie
Caravanserai L’Oasis, 200 beds, Touggourt, Algeria
Saharan homes (detached houses), Touggourt, Algeria
Hotel Les Sables d’Or, 600 beds, Zeralda, Algeria
Hotel with 300 beds, Tamanrasset, Algeria

1969
Prototype “metal house” at the edge of J. Chevallier
, El Ançor, Algeria
Andalusian tourist complex of 2,000 beds, Algiers, Algeria
Hotel with 600 beds, Tipasa Matarès, Algeria
Hotel school for 1600 students, Tizi Ouzou, Algeria

1970
La Breche aux Loups
, 444 detached houses, commercialization, Ozoir-la-Ferrière, France
27 post offices, sorting centers and telephone exchanges, 50,000 m2 realized since, Algeria
Hotel M’Zab (ex-Rost√©mides), 600 beds, Gharda√Įa, Algerie


Several “metallic” houses, Ghazaouate, Algeria
Hotel Les Zianides, 300 beds, Tlemcem, Algeria
43 Villas from 1970 to 1984 in Algiers, Bir Mourad Ra√Įs, Blida, Bouzareah, Draria (Algiers), El Achour, El Biar, Algiers, Kouba, Larbaa, Sahaoula, Sidi A√Įch, Sidi Mohammed, Yakouren

1971
Furnishing of an apartment, place des Vosges
, Paris, France
Theater for 3,600, Sidi Ferruch (surroundings of Algiers), Algeria
Tipaza Club (Algiers area), Algeria
Tourist complex, extension and horse-riding center, (Algiers area), Algeria
Tipasa Matarès (near Algiers), Algeria
Tourist complex, extension, (Algiers area), Algeria
Hotel les Hammadites, extension, Tichy, Algeria
Caravanserai El Gourara, extension, Timimoun, Algeria

1972
Tourist complex, extension, Moretti, Algeria
Village artisanal Plage Ouest: 150 shops and workshops, Sidi Ferruch, Algerie
Resort complex, extension Hotel Mazafran, Zeralda, Algeria
Hotel with 300 beds, Saida, Algeria
Thermal Spa, Hammam Rabbi (Sa√Įda), Algeria
City of 200 apartments, Staoueli (near Algiers), Algeria
Villa des Arcades, transformation of stables into living room and dining room, El Madania, Algiers, Algeria
Technical Unit of SONATOUR, Algiers, Algeria

1973
Prototype “metallic” house, on the property of the president of the PUM (Products of Metallurgical Factories), Sologne, France
Caravanserai The Rym, extension, Beni-Abbes, Algeria
Caravanserai El Mehri, extension, Ouargla, Algeria

1974
Furnishings for a small manor, Chennevières / Marne, France
House of M and Mme V., Gueux, France
Five “metallic” houses, Jonchery / Vesle, France
House-witness of the concept “HOME” (metal house), Val-de-Vesle-Thuisy, France
A “metallic” house, Saint-Brice-Courcelles, France
Residence Lion d’Or, place Drouet d’Erlon, housing, cinema, shopping mall, Reims, France
Galerie du Jardin de Flore, 24 place des Vosges, creation of a flower shop in art gallery, for the publishing company created by Fernand Pouillon, Paris, France
Apartment rue des Fontaines, Algiers, Algeria
Cabaret Dar El Alia, Bouzareah (Algiers), Algeria
Housing development of “metallic” houses, Cheraga, Algeria
Caravanserai El Boustan, extension, El Golea, Algeria
Caravanserai, extension, El Oued, Algeria
Hotel El Djanoub, 600 beds, Gharda√Įa, Algeria
Villa Paradou for the Ministry of Higher Education, Hydra (Algiers), Algeria
Expansion and development of the port, 200 ships of 10 m, La Madrague (near Algiers), Algeria
Development of the port, 400 boats, Sidi Ferruch (Algiers area), Algeria
West Beach Hotel, Sidi Ferruch (surroundings of Algiers), Algeria
West Beach second hotel, in all 1500 beds, West Beach Civic Center of Animation, Sidi Ferruch (surroundings of Algiers), Algeria
Harbor development, 200 boats of 10 meters Hotel with 152 rooms, Skikda, Algeria

1975
Restoration of a house, Peyrusse-le-Roc, France
Offices of Technal International, Toulouse, France
Cité Universitaire for Young Girls, Ben Aknoun, Algeria
Horse-riding center, multi-purpose hall, Tipaza, Algeria
Shopping and leisure center, Tipaza Plage, Algeria
Amraoua Hotel, Tizi Ouzou, Algeria
Tourist complex, extension, multi-purpose hall and facilities, Zeralda, Algeria
Wilaya (prefecture), landscaping, Tlemcem, Albgerie
Ch√Ęteau de Belcastel, restoration (from 1975 to 1983), Belcastel, France

Belcastel1

1976
Monastery for the sisters of Médéa
(Algeria) repatriated to Provence, Cotignac, France
Hotel Plaza, Annaba, Algeria

ab797d597ad3ddb0b8c0b80e33db8e44
Hotel Aurassi, furnishing and decoration, Oued Koreiche (Alger), Algeria
Villa Marguerite, Tlemcem, Algeria

1977
Aménagement du port et extension du centre ville, Saint-Tropez, France
H√ītel, Djemila, Algerie
Cité universitaire, Oran, Algerie

1977-1980
Port development and extension of the city center, Saint-Tropez, France
Hotel, Djemila, Algeria
Cité universitaire, Oran, Algeria

1978
Villas Rochmeboisson
, Ain Benian (Algiers), Algeria
Villa Citro√ęn, Algiers, Algeria
University campus, extension, Ben Aknoun (Algiers), Algeria
Hotel, 600-bed hotel, Constantine, Algeria
Wilaya (prefecture), two projects, Tlemcem, Algeria
Wilaya (prefecture), 3rd project, Tlemcem, Algeria

1979
Cité Universitaire, Ain El Bey (Constantine), Algerie

1979-1982
Cité Universitaire, Ain El Bey (Constantine), Algerie
400 dwellings, Sétif, Algerie
Cité Universitaire for 3,000, Alger, Algerie
Cité Universitaire for 5,000, Bab Ezzouar (Alger), Algerie
Cité Universitaire for 2,000, Batna, Algerie
Cité Universitaire for 2,500, Constantine, Algerie
Cité Universitaire for 2,000, Mostaganem, Algerie
Cité Universitaire for 2,000, Oran, Algerie
Cité Universitaire for 2,000, Sidi Bel Abbès, Algerie

1980
House F, Belcastel, France
Map of the new town, competition, Saint-Quentin-en-Yveline, France
City of 400 dwellings, Boufarik, Algeria
Bus station 40,000 m2, Constantine, Algeria
Spa, extension, Hammam Rabbi (Sa√Įda), Algeria
Post Office, Touggourt, Algerie

1981
Hotel El Djaza√Įr
(formerly Saint-Georges), resumption and continuation of works, Algiers, Algeria

1982
House extension project, Eschentzwiller, France
Hotel El Djaza√Įr (ex Saint-Georges), extension, Algiers, Algeria
City of 400 dwellings, Blida, Algeria
Boulevard belt interior, layout plan, Sidi Bel Abbès, Algerie

The Hotel El-Djaza√Įr was completed in record time to coincide with the twentieth anniversary of Algerian independence but the government never paid the fees, causing Pouillon to default on, in turn, social security contributions, taxes, and then wages. Pouillon abandoned Algeria and returned to France where he¬†was reinstated¬†to the¬†Order of Architects but the tax debt of the CNL was still outstanding. President Mitterrand forgave Pouillon the¬†CNL debt and made him¬†an¬†Officer of the Legion of Honor in 1984.

1984
Computing Center for the Ministry of Culture
, Montigny-le-Bretonneux, France

1985
Thirty detached houses on an air base
, Avord, France
Masterplan for 4,000 housing units, Créteil, France
Europarc activity zone plan, two buildings realized in collaboration with Schott firm), Créteil, France
Music Conservatory, rue Armand Carrel, 19th arrondissement
Social housing 172 avenue Jean-Jaurès, 19th arrondissement
Apartment rue de Bièvre, development and extension, 5th arrondissement
Apartment rue Boissy d’Anglas, development and extension, 8th arrondissement

Undated
Development of an abbey
in a secondary residence, Belhomert-Guehouville, Algerie
Building for SNECMA, Corbeil, France
A swimming pool in the rock by the sea for M and Mme B., Normandy, France
Avenue Montaigne, private apartment, Paris, France
Georges V, Georges V Avenue, after 1970 Private apartment, rue Surcouf, Paris, France
Restoration of
Manoir du Jonchet, Romilly / Aigre, France
Studies for an unidentified program, Monaco, France
Villas “Les Jardins Exotiques”, Monte-Carlo, France
Maxim’s Restaurant, Montreal, Canada
Maxim’s Restaurant, after 1965, Tokyo, Japan
Apartment rue Didouche Mourad, Algiers, Algeria
Hotel, Biskra, Algeria
New Hotel, 600 beds, Constantine, France
Hotel, 150 rooms, Djanet, Algeria
Bordj of the Chevalier family, extension, El Biar (Algiers), Algeria
Caravanserai, Hotel du Souf, El Oued, Algeria
Hotel El Mordjane, La Calle (El Kala), Algeria
Apartment hotel of 1,000 beds, La Calle (El Kala), Algeria
Depot garage, communal Market Cinema Theater, Laghouat, France
Caravanserai, Madakh, Algeria
Villas, Sahaoula, Algeria
La Grande Plage Resort (Sidi Begra), Sera√Įdi, Algeria
Hotel du Port, Sera√Įdi, Algeria
Hotel El Marsa Olympic Swimming Pool Quartier du Corsaire Restaurant, Sera√Įdi, Algeria

Sidi Fredj / Sidi-Ferruch – Alger wilaya – Algeria / Alg√ąrie: Hotel El Marsa and Hotel El Manar | H√ôtels El Marsa et El Manar – photo by M.Torres

Holiday village, Sidi Okba Oumache, Skikda A√Įn Ben Noui, Algeria
Complex: theater, bungalows, restaurant, port, Tipaza La Corne d’Or, Algeria
Hotel Esmeralda, Tipaza Plage, Algeria
Cité Universitaire, Tlemcem, Algeria
Complex of Courbet Marine, Zemmouri, Algeria
Administrative Center One Hotel, Zeralda, Algeria
Hotel La Residence, Zeralda, Algeria
Villas in Ain El Hammam, Ain Taya, Draa Esmar, El Biar (Algiers), In Nadjah, Hydra (Algiers), Kraicia

Unrealized
Additionally, there are approx. 800 unrealized projects in France alone.

prolific!

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

Seven possible reasons why Fernand Pouillon is not better remembered than he is.

  1. His main period of activity as an architect was¬†over the period 1932‚Äď1961 ‚Äď a period corresponding to the heyday of Le Corbusier. Perhaps the world of architecture didn’t need another architect from France when they already had someone contributing so much¬†to the mythology of architecture and architects.
  2. Reconstruction and rehabilitation¬†are both good things but both only¬†restore and improve upon what was already present. They¬†don’t add to the mythology of¬†architecture in such a way as did Le Corbusier’s Unit√© d’Habitations that put Marseille on the map.¬†
  3. Or perhaps¬†the world of architecture did not need anything else from Algeria, since¬†it already had¬†Le Corbusier’s Plan Obus which is vastly over-remembered, especially when compared with his¬†earlier proposal for Algiers.LC1
  4. The period 1956‚Äď1961 when the Algerian Uprising was changing into¬†the Algerian War and Pouillon, like Chevalier, would have deen (rightly) suspected of having Algerian separatist sympathies. This period coincides with the time¬†people would¬†have been¬†collecting evidence against Pouillon and making a case for his imprisonment.
  5. Not only that, Pouillon¬†was a member of the communist party until about¬†1943. After that, he would have been remembered as having been a member of the communist party until about¬†1943. The period 1947‚Äď1956 coincided with United States’ doctrine of¬†McCarthyism¬†that persecuted persons suspected of being either communists or of having communist sympathies. Fernand Pouillon may thus have suffered the same fate as¬†Hannes Meyer, Karel Teige¬†and Andr√© Lur√ßat.¬†Architecture prefers fascist governments and their rallying¬†monuments to¬†communist ones and their dreary obsession with mass housing.
  6. Pouillon was never stylistically experimental for the sake of it. If Brutalism had had construction advantages we would no doubt see more Pouillon buildings in concrete. He experimented with metallic housing and prefabrication in the seventies, long after it had been fashionable. His career also overlapped Post Modernism but he had no need for semiotics beyond indicating home and neighbourhood by conventional means. His sensibility towards reconstruction and restoration was also off-trend.
  7. Pouillon is responsible for the design of an enormous number¬†of buildings, many of which are regarded as fine or outstanding. The sheer volume¬†of his output shows he was extremely skilled at promoting his services but that he is not remembered has a lot to do with him being more interested in building than in designing¬†his mythology ‚Äď a trait he shares with many¬†of the other misfit architects.

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

fernand-pouillon

Fernand Pouillon!

Your service to the community began long before your imprisonment
and continued long after.

misfits salutes you!

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

  • www.fernandpouillon.com is the most comprehensive resource there is. I’m indebted.
  • http://publishing.cdlib.org¬†a substantial website on post-war housing in Algeria
  • http://www.jeanlucmichel.com is a blog (in French) with a fine collection of images of many otherwise unphotographed Fernand Pouillon buildings. The¬†photographs are more photo-journalism¬†than architectural photography and make you feel as if you had been¬†there walking around looking at the buildings and taken¬†the photographs¬†yourself. The¬†unstaged photographs are¬†real and, because of that, informative and, because of that, refreshing.
  • http://www.bdonline.co.uk¬†links to article about La Tourette inspiring the UK architect Adam Khan
  • Adam Caruso and Helen Thomas (Hg.): The Stones of Fernand Pouillon ‚Äď An Alternative Modernism in French Architecture. gta Verlag, Z√ľrich 2013, ISBN 978-3-85676-324-4.

¬†‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

Pouillon’s¬†infamous¬†system for coordinating all construction¬†activity may have had its flaws but it did produce high quality and affordable housing that, seventy years on, has aged well, is not dated, and is still eminently liveable.¬†A system that could produce results of such high quality under budget and in record time goes¬†is not a system geared towards stakeholders systematically milking¬†the budget by inflating or falsifying invoices. It defies¬†conventional thinking.

Exactly how Pouillon brought the 2,635 apartments of the 1959 Résidence du Parc in Meudon-la-Forêt (1959) online in record time and at less than market prices remains a mystery no-one seems to want to see solved.

2445909041_small_2.jpg

Architecture Misfit #28: Harold Krantz

harold-krantz

Abraham Harold Krantz
[1906 ‚Äď 1999]

  • 1906: Born in Adelaide, Australia, to Russian Jewish parents
  • 1926: Qualified as an architect and worked for Woods, Bagot, Jory & Laybourne-Smith
  • 1927: Moved to Perth to work for¬†Oldham, Boas & Ednie-Brown
  • 1929:¬†Registered as an architect

1929 was not a great¬†year to start¬†a career. It was the beginning of The Great Depression that was to last until 1939. For the first two years Krantz ran a poster studio with John Oldham, son of his earlier boss John¬†Oldham Snr. He and Oldham¬†were¬†able to make a living producing lino cut poster prints, many¬†for the Australian Communist Party of which Oldham was a member. Krantz was to¬†later recall how running this business made him¬†look for¬†ways¬†of getting the cost down without spoiling the quality. ¬†Krantz’s first designs for buildings¬†were simple ones aiming at cost efficiency. They had to be if they were¬†to have any¬†chance of being¬†built.

“It had to be as functional as possible with no frills, no decoration, the use of colour and materials, good planning, no waste of space, no passages and no breaks and funny shapes. The objective was to study every element in the building from the skirting, from the foundations, up to the top of the roof. Is there a better way of doing it for the same money, or a better job for less, or just as good a job for less money?”

Even as a reminiscence, this is amazing for the late thirties. These next two projects from 1936 are catalogued by Australian National University as Oldham’s but signed by Krantz. The automobiles won’t have been realistic for mid-Depression Australia so these are probably speculative designs, or possibly the research that¬†architects typically turn to in lean times. For Australia, these buildings proposed a new way of living. They weren’t trying to be houses. In the one¬†on the left, the grade is being used for car parking and the absence of gardens compensated for by the roof terrace.

The hope for¬†better times isn’t¬†being displayed¬†as architectural¬†excess. The¬†symmetry about the entrance suggests¬†minimal internal circulation with¬†two apartments per landing. Even when times were better,¬†Krantz was still¬†never one to waste building volume.

It’s not surprising¬†that some of Krantz’s first built projects were for small multiple-occupation dwellings in the wealthier parts of Perth towards the end of The Depression.

‚ÄėMelleray‚Äô Flats, 1938
Corner Winthrop Ave and Hardy Road, Hollywood, Perth

“Coronel’ Flats, Harold Krantz, 1938
Corner Fairway and Clark Street, Nedlands 

The four flats give the illusion of a large house by the asymmetrical front elevation and by having the entrances on the sides. [It’s odd to think that between 1974 and 1978 I spent most of my daylight hours and¬†a fair share of the nightime ones within 200 metres of this building.]

These apartment blocks must date from not too long after as the same principles are used in larger blocks, and repeated. Amazingly, some still remain.

These are the 1938 Riviera flats. There’s no hint of the jazz, cocktails and fast cars of the 1936 proposals, but the fact they were built in¬†1938¬†proves¬†the concept was timely and achievable. Once again there are two flats per landing.

100331

Arbordale, Perth and Greenways, Adelaide, 1939

Nedlands Tennis Club, Harold Krantz, 1939

Krantz was a member of the Nedlands Tennis Club and designed its new clubhouse. With tenders advertised in January 1938 for AUS£1,600 including some restrained Art-Deco trim, this was a major project signalling the end of the building downturn.

Nedlands Tennis Club

fullsizeoutput_f83

Krantz’s¬†approach to architecture was thus¬†well established by 1939 when¬†Robert Schl√§flik arrived from Europe and began working for him. Schl√§flik registered as an architect in 1946, changed his surname to Sheldon, and the firm of Krantz & Sheldon began.

Building flats allowed Krantz the opportunity to more fully develop and apply the principles he had already established in his work on houses, that being an

  1. emphasis on reducing each dwelling unit to a minimum, achieved by tight planning rather than smaller spaces;
  2. conventional construction combined with rigorous detailing to maximise structural strength of building materials and minimise waste; and
  3. the bulk ordering of standard building materials, fixtures and fittings to achieve economies of scale. [architecture.com.au]

This is all brilliant in itself but another innovation was the system for funding some of the earlier buildings.¬†“He organised friends, family and business colleagues into syndicates who would pool their resources to finance new building projects, particularly flats. These syndicates allowed small investors direct access to property investment. Significantly, as the syndicates were primarily for investment, Krantz and Sheldon was able to pursue design ideas without the restrictions of individual preferences.”¬†[ibid] Those design ideas¬†weren’t¬†design ideas as we may understand the term today but ways of constructing¬†accommodation¬†more efficiently.

People in Perth did not take quickly to the idea of living in apartments.¬†Newspapers were critical of flats as the¬†“the slums of tomorrow’.¬†In 1941 Krantz defended the building of flats in an¬†article for The Architect magazine. He claimed ‚Äėslums are low return propositions; whether small cottages, large luxury residences or flats of any kind‚Äô. This is a¬†valid statement¬†if the¬†apartments are¬†for sale and not for rent.¬†

In 1953, the Western Australian State Housing Commission commissioned Krantz & Sheldon to design the Wandana housing project in Subiaco. It included ten-storey block containing 242 apartments. Upon its completion in 1956 Krantz once again had to defend apartment living. 

response.jpeg

Wandana Housing, Krantz & Sheldon, 1956
93 Thomas Street, Subiaco

Krantz & Sheldon remained the predominant designers of flats in Perth through to the 1970s, with some estimates suggesting the firm designed as much as 90% of Perth’s flats up to this time. In response to limits on building materials, and to keep maintenance to a minimum, their designs pursued functionalism and included features such as minimal decoration, unpainted timbers, face brickwork, cream painted finishes.

Here’s their Caringal Apartments. The effect is¬†like Danish Modernism but achieved with materials having a high cost-performance. I say that because parquet flooring would not have been the least expensive option and because Krantz knew¬†the physical¬†properties of linoleum.

Playhouse Theatre, Harold Krantz, 1956
[demolished but formerly in Pier Street, Perth]

rdk-03

Many Krantz & Sheldon buildings had¬†face brickwork and it has been their fate to be painted. This happened with Hillside Gardens and even more recently with the partial¬†painting of Fremantle’s¬†Johnson Court¬†that¬†featured in The Homestead Myth.

Hillside Gardens, Krantz & Sheldon, 1963
59-65 Malcolm Street, West Perth

This real estate listing will hopefully still take you around the interior of an apartment at Hillside Gardens. 

In Australia, internal face brickwork elicits the same reaction as raw concrete does in the UK and for the same reason ‚Äď class prejudice. Beauty = Expensive therefore Inexpensive¬†= Ugly. Internal face brickwork was never intended as a fashion statement so it’s impossible for it to have gone out of fashion. If we don’t see so much of it today it’s not that we grew out of the look but because we like to think we can¬†afford “better”. The same prejudice¬†lives on. This is ironic because we can’t afford better. Over time, the quality of workmanship declined to the extent it became cheaper to build¬†sloppily using second-rate materials and then cover it all up after with plaster and paint. “Architectural aesthetics is a smokescreen for economic exploitation.” Discuss. There’s no architectural aesthetics on display in this next photograph. Instead, the good life is depicted by the¬†television, flowers, the palm tree and the dinner party about to happen with three courses, chargers, napkins, and the promise of wine.

100x125mm

Interior makeovers have occurred at Johnson Court and many other Krantz & Sheldon apartment buildings but the bathrooms remain¬†next to the¬†kitchen for¬†simplified plumbing, easier maintenance and natural ventilation. Some things¬†resist being¬†changed because there’s no way they¬†can be improved upon.

The 1950s and 1960s were the golden years of flat building in Perth and nobody made a greater contribution to it than Krantz & Sheldon. Their apartments were of many types and sizes, and for budgets and sites of all sizes. All share the same pragmatic planning, construction, and servicing. All of the photographs you see here are used with the permission of the State Library of Western Australia.

There were also commissions for hotels.

Riverside Lodge is the most central of these. I include it here to show what building visualizations once looked like. It’s still there,¬†and Mt. Eliza Apartments can still be seen in the background.

Riverside Lodge, Krantz & Sheldon
Mounts Bay Road, Perth

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

This links to a site¬†that¬†remembers Krantz’s actress wife Dororthy (and hence the connection with the Playhouse Theatre). There, it states that the 1964 Mount Eliza Apartments¬†effectively marked the change in generation from Harold Krantz to son David.¬†

img_3171

Windsor Towers, which also featured in Misfits’ Guide to Perth, is from 1966.

Sheldon died in 1968 and Krantz retired in 1972.¬†Krantz’s son David continued the practice with other partners Robin Arndt, John Silbert, George Sheldon (who I imagine¬†is Robert Sheldon’s son) and Lourens West. The firm traded as¬†Arndt, Silbert and West (KSASW) and later as Team Architects Australia. I believe it was later absorbed¬†into Oldham Boas Ednie Brown and, if that’s so, is a case of the firm ending back where it began. Oldham Boas Ednie Brown now trades as¬†The Buchan Group¬†which is one of those global architectural consortiums¬†that claim “a track record of excellence of service and design” or what passes for it these days.¬†

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

harold-krantz

Abraham Harold Krantz!

For developing a viable new housing product at the end of the Great Depression,

fullsizeoutput_f84.jpeg

for preparing the ground for¬†an efficient new housing type of “minimum” flats in Perth,

100334

for your ceaseless efforts to make apartment buildings acceptable and affordable,

fullsizeoutput_f88

for promoting a housing type, a construction system to build it,
developing a philosophy for its design and construction,
and for succeeding in rolling it out across Perth,
with various adaptions for site, orientation and budget.

glendalough 2

misfits’ salutes you!

Harold Krantz: Architecture Misfit #28

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

The Western Australia Apartment Advocacy (http://www.waaa.net.au) is continuing the work Harold Krantz began and works to promote apartment living in Perth and raise awareness of its advantages.

It was in 1941 when Harold Krantz first had to defend apartment living against a hostile public. Ninety years on, the WA Apartment Advocacy still has their work cut out for them. 

fullsizeoutput_f9f

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

Architecture Misfit #25: Ernst May

Zur ausschlie√ülichen Verwendung in der Online-Ausstellung "K√ľnste im Exil" (www.kuenste-im-exil.de). Originaldateiname: VA_KIE_DKA_0084_May.tif Eindeutiger Identifier: VA_KIE_DKA_0084_May.jpg

Ernst May
[July 1886 ‚ÄĒ September 1970]

New Frankfurt¬†[in German, Neues Frankfurt] was an affordable¬†public housing¬†program in¬†Frankfurt¬†started in 1925 and completed in 1930.¬†The mayor of Frankfurt hired Ernst May¬†as general manager of the project to¬†bring together architects to work on it. The goal was housing that could be rented for¬†no more than 25% of¬†a person’s monthly income.

May’s developments were remarkable for their time for being compact. The 60 sq.m.¬†area of a typical three-room apartment was fifteen sq.m. less than the standard for the time. Economic pressures led to two-room apartments for four people having an area of 40¬†¬†sq.m. These were known as transitional minimum subsistence dwellings. The plan was to later combine them into larger units.

The housing units were semi-independent, well-equipped with community elements like playgrounds, schools, theatres, and common washing areas. This is admirable.

May used simplified, prefabricated forms for the sake of economy and construction speed. This shows a comprehension of the scale and urgency of the problem.

ernstmay

The settlements were planned to have new ideals such as equal access to sunlight, air, and common areas. This was most progressive.

The settlement layouts and the dwellings and their spaces were highly functional. This was not the pursuit of functionalism as a style, but a means of not wasting space and the building materials to enclose it.

esszimmer-im-ernst-may-haus-foto-barbara-staubach

The development of the Frankfurt Kitchen in 1926 by¬†Austrian¬†architect¬†Margarete (Grete) Sch√ľtte-Lihotzky¬†was one of the offshoots of their joint research. It was the first unit¬†kitchen.

May was responsible for the production of approximately¬†15,000¬†housing units between¬†1925 and 1932.¬†This is¬†a huge achievement for¬†any person in any country in¬†any era, but was in Germany during¬†a period of¬†INCREASING¬†POLITICAL TURMOIL¬†‚Äď a¬†period that, as it happened, coincided with¬†the heyday of¬†the Bauhaus.

Here’s what happened.

585x364x05_-FK-Kurhessenstrasse1.jpg.pagespeed.ic.i1uZKsqSED

Estate H√∂henblick, Frankfurt am Main, 1926‚Äď1927

0538359ba9d24a4883d042ebb33eb3d6

Estate Bruchfeldstra√üe (Zickzackhausen), Frankfurt am Main, 1926‚Äď1927

resize_may_praunheim_01

Estate Praunheim, Frankfurt am Main, 1926‚Äď1928

d5e51ade7ea3fb62a50498e63f9e0c87

Estate R√∂merstadt, Frankfurt am Main, 1926‚Äď1928

l2_v324630_958_480_284-8

Estate Bornheimer Hang, Frankfurt am Main, 1926‚Äď1930

fm932682a36yji

Estate Heimatsiedlung, Frankfurt am Main, 1927‚Äď1934

1462802_2_l

Estate Westhausen, Frankfurt am Main, 1929‚Äď1931

fm932685a9zx53

Estate Westhausen, Frankfurt am Main, 1929‚Äď1931

Johnson & Hitchcock have nothing to say about May, save for this parenthesised reference on p233 of The International Style. 

Ernst May.png

Others however noticed. May achievements were recognised at the 1929 CIAM conference. This brought him to the attention of the Soviet Union.

In 1930 May took virtually his entire¬†New Frankfurt-team to Russia.¬†…¬†The promise of the “Socialist¬†paradise” was still fresh, and May’s Brigade and other groups of western planners had the hope of constructing entire cities. The first was to be Magnitogorsk. Although May’s group is indeed credited with building 20 cities in three years,¬†the reality was that May found Magnitogorsk already under construction and the town site dominated by the mine. Officials were indecisive, then distrustful, corruption and delay frustrated their efforts, and May himself made misjudgements about the climate. May’s contract expired in 1933, and he left for Kenya (then British East Africa).

May’s reputation¬†thus went the same way as Architecture Misfit #1: Hannes Meyer¬†and Architecture Misfit #23: Andr√© Lur√ßat.¬†May is not mentioned much in the history of modern architecture. It’s not just because he went to the Soviet Union when other German architects were busy brushing up their¬†English. May¬†was a professional who, when given¬†the problem of providing housing for the country’s population, didn’t see his role as developing prototypes for mass production, but to¬†actually¬†make it happen.¬†And he did. 15,000 of them. And they’re still lived in.

frankfurt-praunheim_am_ebelfeld_a1

Despite existing from¬†1919‚Äď1932, the Bauhaus contributed little to solving Germany’s housing¬†problem. Gropius’¬†Dessau-T√∂rten Estate¬†of 1926‚Äď1928 provided 317 dwellings with¬†areas of 57‚Äď75 sqm but it was a job on the side, independent of his¬†1919‚Äď1928 stint as Bauhaus director. Gropius put the experience to good use and,¬†immediately upon leaving the Bauhaus in 1928, won a competition for the design of¬†Dammerstock Colony. In 1934 he was to leave Germany and its mass housing problems behind him forever.

Dammerstock_vista_aerea_desde_oeste.jpg

For¬†the period 1926‚Äď1928 at the very least, Gropius was involved with both architectural education and the solving of real-world¬†housing¬†problems but, for a person renowned¬†as an educator, the thought that education might be about training people to solve real-world problems never seems to have crossed his mind.¬†He kept education and real-world problems very¬†separate. It didn’t do his career any harm but, if we were to ask when¬†the rot set in, it would be here.¬†I use the term architectural education loosely, as Gropius must have¬†on his CV, for it¬†was Hannes Meyer who added¬†architecture to the Bauhaus curriculum. And it was Meyer who¬†connected architecture¬†with¬†the solving of real-world problems, only for Mies to separate it¬†again.¬†What happened afterwards ‚Äď and, unfortunately for us ‚Äď ¬†is not history.

It’s often said Hitler’s preference for pitched roofs was responsible for the dissolution of the Bauhaus. Perhaps¬†it was, but Ernst May still managed to get 15,000 flat-roofed housey things built before leaving Germany in 1930, four years before Gropius and eight years before Mies. May’s leaving¬†was the¬†greater loss for Germany. In 1954 he¬†was invited back and began work at the planning department of the City of Hamburg.

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

tumblr_m1d9dp2amr1qgfyua

Ernst May!

for knowing what had to be done in order to deliver,
and doing it.

misfits salutes you!

Architecture Misfit #23: André Lurçat

0f3205a56bbb728ed10837742104cf30.jpg
André Lurçat
[1894 ‚Äď 1970]

Andr√© Lur√ßat was¬†born three years after¬†Charles-√Čdouard Jeanneret-Gris¬†and died¬†five years after Le Corbusier’s final swim.¬†Lur√ßat was not only a French modernist architect active over the same period, but also a¬†landscape architect, furniture designer, urban¬†planner and¬†founding member of CIAM. His and¬†Le Corbusier’s careers were mostly parallel until the late 1920s when they¬†diverged as much as it is possible for the careers of two architects to diverge.

Lur√ßat was born in Bruy√®res, studied at the √Čcole des Beaux-Arts in Nancy, and worked in the office of Robert Mallet-Stevens.¬†In the twenties, Lur√ßat¬†was¬†in the loop¬†and¬†counted amongst the movers and shakers.¬†His architectural ideas were very much a product of that¬†time and that means they were generally pretty good. Here’s his¬†1925 Maison pour M. Bomsel in Versailles. It still exists.

cb0e4a6c5ecd19986992655f0196772a

[1920’s Versailles was a bit of an architectural hotspot. Here’s Auguste Perret’s 1924¬†Maison Cassandre. It still exists.]

 

 

 

This is¬†Lur√ßat’s 1926¬†Casa Guggenbuhl in Paris,

Andre_Lurcat._Villa_Guggenbuhl.3

his 1926-7 Casa Froriep de Salis in Boulogne,

259px-AndreLurcat.CasaFroriepdeSalis.1

and a Parisian double house with the two names of Maison Double de Frank Townshend and Villa Seurat, on Villa Seurat, after the painter.

Villa Seurat

Adrian Yekkes’ blog tells us¬†Lur√ßat was¬†responsible for nos. 3 and 4 Villa Seurat which were his own home, as well as 5, 8, 9 and 11. [Auguste Perret and Ze’ev Rechter did 7a. No. 6 is also interesting.] Let’s take a walk.¬†It’s quite the enclave.¬†No. 3 is Lur√ßat’s house with the bowed facade and his office must have been 4 across the road with the plants. Here we also see no. 5.¬†

3,4,5 Villa Seurat

No. 11 is the one with the sun reflecting.

No. 11 Villa Seurat

Of¬†the same period¬†was¬†Lur√ßat’s Housing in Villeneuve-Saint-George. This was featured in the Russian Constructivist journal SA issue 6 in 1927. The plans show a concern for housing many people with dignity and without wasted resources.

img277

In 1929, André Lurçat was one of the three architects Charles de Beistégui asked for a proposal to remodel his apartment on the Champs-Elysées. Never knew that.

vignettes

Lur√ßat’s 1929¬†Hotel Nord-Sud¬†in Calvi, Corsica is relatively¬†well known as it was included in Johnson and Hitchcock’s¬†1932 book¬†The International Style¬†which, as we know, was a hit and miss affair. The hotel is very much the¬†artificial object juxtaposed with Nature which, depending on what you want to believe, is either some contrived Modernist aesthetic or precisely¬†what to expect¬†when you build an artificial object on a piece of¬†rugged¬†landscape.

nord-sud3

Note how the dining room offers a different experience by not facing the water. The library has little daylighting or views, presumably for the same reason.

hotel nord-sud

It’s still a hotel.

3e4a1f223efcc3bc2704fc8694ad5b44

Here’s Lur√ßat’s¬†1930 proposal for a vertical city, six years after LC’s La Ville Radieuse,¬†but the solar orientation makes it very much in line with the theme of the 1930 CIAM conference which was rational lot development (in terms of sunlight penetration and health).

tumblr_liuhesWpeW1qe0nlvo1_500.jpg

This next project is the Karl-Marx Middle School, in Villejuif from 1931-1933. Not enclosing the ground level [a.k.a. “raising the building”]¬†is normally an¬†expensive way to shelter and entrance but, with school buildings, the¬†additional¬†covered¬†outdoor space at ground level makes sense since open area isn’t sacrificed to create sheltered area. ¬†

The building is still there, and still a middle school.

Along with Adolf Loos, Richard Neutra, Margarete Sch√ľtte-Lihotzky and others, he demonstrated a family residence at the Vienna Werkbund exhibition of 1932,

That’s not a very accurate description ‚Äď it’s aims were somewhat greater.

produced his best-known Villa Hefferlin at Ville-d’Avray,

This looks rather lovely and a nice residential solution to a narrow plot, and a very elegant French take on Rationalism. Check out the plan. Those are nice rooms.

Lur√ßat¬†was always on the edge of greater recognition. His¬†buildings aimed higher than most and some are¬†rather good solutions to the problems he set out to solve. What happened? Why we don’t know more about Andr√© Lur√ßat?

then went to Moscow to work for the Soviet government from 1934 to 1937.

That’ll be it then. We should have guessed from the plan of Hotel Nord-Sud. Now we look at it closely, is not unlike a communal house in that it¬†lacks a living room, and has¬†a communal dining room and bathrooms. The memory and reputation of Andr√© Lur√ßat then, went much the same way as Hannes Meyer’s did in 1933.¬†Lur√ßat left the Soviet Union in¬†1937, the same year Frank Lloyd Wright addressed the First Soviet Council of Architects at the height of ¬†Stalin’s Great Terror.

Lurçat is known for advancing the cause of modernism in landscape architecture; he took a position, contrary to the proponents of Existenzminimum, that all social housing must include gardens.

In retrospect, we can see this interest in the 1925 Maison pour M. Bomsel. The garden is carefully laid out, as if it wanted to be a vegetable garden.

He is also known for his planned postwar reconstruction of the French city of Maubeuge [just north of Paris]. He was a professor at the √Čcole nationale sup√©rieure des Arts D√©coratifs and the √Čcole nationale sup√©rieure des Beaux-Arts in Paris from 1945 to 1947, and a member of the board of architecture of the Ministry of Reconstruction and Urban Development.

There’s an unsurprising gap between 1937 when Lur√ßat¬†returned from the Soviet Union and the 1945 masterplan. Lur√ßat¬†did no work¬†for¬†the 1940-1944 Vichy government. Lur√ßat’s appointment to the Ministry of Reconstruction and Urban Development shows a¬†desire to be¬†of use.

reconstruction1reconstruction2

There are many other photos of the reconstructed Maubeuge¬†on the town’s tourism website.¬†It’s the type of low-rise, high-density housing Europe needed.

L-architecture-Lurcat-la-Mail-de-la-Sambre

Lur√ßat’s¬†next known work is a house for himself in 1948 in Sceaux, about midway between Paris and Orly.

It’s adjacent¬†to one he designed for a neighbour,¬†Jules Leduc. Lur√ßat¬†never let go of the importance of gardens.

I’m reminded of Cesare Cattaneo’s 1939¬†Casa d’affitto a Cernobbio.¬†It makes me think Lur√ßat, like the Italians, found no reason to abandon Rationalism as a way of building.¬†

07.Cattaneo_casa-cernobbio

Here’s his¬†1958¬†L’√©glise st Pierre st Paul in Maubeuge.

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

There’s more to Andr√© Lur√ßat than I’ve been able to mention. A¬†full chronology is¬†here,¬†listed by location and date and with links. I’ve recompiled it below. Between the masterplan work which continued at least until 1958, and 1970 when he died, Lur√ßat’s prodigious output is mostly¬†municipal, comprising¬†schools, social centres, municipal gymnasiums, sports stadiums and social housing. At least ten projects were completed posthumously.

  • If he is remembered at all, Lur√ßat¬†is usually remembered for that part of his career that parallelled Le Corbusier’s, even though¬†the buildings aren’t¬†indicative of his long-term concerns¬†or even his output as a whole.
  • Everything Lur√ßat did after¬†1932 was,¬†and continues¬†to be,¬†redacted according to¬†the¬†socially-cleansed architectural criteria¬†put forth by¬†Johnson and Hitchcock.

It’s clear to me now. What Lur√ßat and¬†all the other misfit architects identified on this blog have in common are 1)¬†a sense of social responsibility¬†coupled with 2)¬†a professional and personal integrity. No ‚Äď I don’t believe these qualities make Lur√ßat or any of the others all that¬†exceptional but, when compared with those¬†architects around whom the history and mythology of architecture are constructed, yes ‚Äď they do.

A few years before Lur√ßat¬†died, the Greek junta (1967-1974) banned him,¬†along with civil liberties, political parties, strikes, labor unions, the music of composer Mikas Theodorakis, long hair on men, mini-skirts, the peace symbol, The Beatles, Sophocles, Tolstoy, Aeschylus, Socrates, Eugene Lonesco, Sartre, Chekhov, Mark Twain, Samuel Beckett, free press, new math and the letter Z. All in all, it’s not bad¬†company.

baniere

A¬†school in Maubeuge is named after Lur√ßat. I’m glad.

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

andre-lurcat_paris-1952_large

André Lurçat

for believing that being an architect
meant doing the right thing
for the people of your country

misfits’ salutes you!

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

CHRONOLOGIQUE CHRONOLOGY

Architecture Misfits #22: H Arquitectes

For too long, Lacaton & Vassal have been the only living architecture misfits, consistently producing buildings of high utility, great economy and stark beauty. H Arquitectes readily admit to being influenced by Lacaton & Vassal and their readiness to acknowledge it immediately marks them as different. Their Casa Gualba appeared in the Dec. 2012 post The New Architecture of Austerity.

712-harquitectes-casa-barcelona-01

It’s time for a better look at what H Arquitectes are about. I half expect there to be no more or less than what we see. If so, they would be the second living misfits and¬†the¬†second known instance of Post-Media Architects¬†designing buildings to be buildings and not as vehicles for fame.

Website: http://www.harquitectes.com

harquitectos.jpg

The buildings described¬†on their website say it better than I might say here, and this too is a positive. H Arquitectes aren’t designing buildings for others to write¬†things such as¬†I’m about to.

At first glance H Arquitectes’¬†website appears constructed for looks rather than convenience because projects are accessed by icons scattered¬†across the screen. This was mildly exasperating to begin with but, after a while, I realised it was telling me to slow down and take some time to explore. It worked.

The rewards are immediate. Clicking an icon loads a slideshow that, in some cases, shows stages of construction and how the thing gets built. Fancy that!

1219-harquitectes-casa-barcelona-03

Photographs of construction are there because somebody thought they were important and we might like to know. I can present them to you because all images are downloadable. I like these people. The forward > button can be difficult to find at times but, after viewing a few projects, you’ll get a feel for where it is and you won’t mind.

I haven’t trawled the internet to gauge their media presence but, from what I’ve seen,¬†H Arquitectes prefer to let their projects speak for themselves. H Arquitectes buildings may sometimes look similar but even the ones that don’t, share¬†a similarity of approach. An approach is not a look or a style. I want to highlight this consistency of approach because if they can use it to make buildings that aren’t copies of themselves, then so too can everybody else.

1. Simple planning integrated with structure

712-harquitectes-casa-barcelona-20

  • Casa Gualba, above, I’ve mentioned before. It’s self-stabilising layout produces six peripheral acute angles, three of which dissolve into windows and the other three of which lead to them.¬†The central¬†corridor is space that makes the entire plan work.¬†There is no hallway. The kitchen is where people arrive and are met.
  • Casa Barcelona¬†may remind you of¬†Peso von Ellrichshausen’s¬†Casa Meri¬†but is less forced. Different things such as¬†a garage and a¬†machine room accessed externally, and an outdoor area are allowed to happen within the volume of the¬†building.1219-harquitectes-casa-barcelona-21-2[for comparison, PvE’s Casa Meri]Meri-house-by-Pezo-von-Ellrichshausen_dezeen_4

Casa Escala¬†has a plan and structure that couldn’t be more integrated, but the same could be said of all their other projects.

1217-harquitectes-casa-escala-22

2. Simple construction integrated with materials

Many of H Arquitectes’ buildings make the same points. This is a corner of Casa Gualba. This is not some cheap trick. To¬†save yourself some time and labour cutting bricks, you have to make sure the same thing will happen at the other end of the wall as well. All three sides/runs¬†need to be carefully¬†dimensioned.

712-harquitectes-casa-barcelona-09

Window openings all fall on half bricks, as they should.

712-harquitectes-casa-barcelona-16.jpg

3. Integrated construction and building science

The website text for¬†Casa Costa Brava¬†includes words such as¬†sun protection in summer ‚ÄĘ sun‚Äôs radiation in the winter ‚ÄĘ mosquito net ‚ÄĘ thermal bridge ‚Äʬ†double glass ‚Äʬ†ventilated fa√ßade ‚ÄĘ ‚Äʬ†full construction opening ‚Äʬ†interior bearing wall ‚Äʬ†insulation ‚ÄĘ thermal inertia ‚ÄĘ air tightness ‚Äʬ†condensation ‚ÄĘ cracking ‚ÄĘ reduced weight ‚ÄĘ self-supporting main beams¬†‚ÄĘ lack of¬†formwork.¬†These are all things H Arquitectes¬†thought were important and thought¬†we should¬†know about. They are. We should.

4. The absence of the concept of ‘interior’

When construction is integrated with materials and executed with care, the result is beautiful. This photograph is the interior of Casa Barcelona. It’s obvious that what the architects have done is provide a shell for living¬†without making any demands¬†for how that living should take place. This approach is shared with Lacaton & Vassal and it’s a useful and liberating one for both¬†buildings and their inhabitants.

1219-harquitectes-casa-barcelona-15

5. Economy of resources 1

When a practice completes¬†such a thoughtful body of work in their first sixteen years, it’s always a worry that larger commissions and¬†bigger budgets will kill off¬†the drive¬†to innovate and invent. Fortunately, how to build intelligently with a minium of resources is one bigger issue that remains¬†relevant at any scale. Their Centre Civic Cristalerias Planell in Barcelona.

1015-harquitectes-equipament-civic-cristalerias-planell-30

It is being constructed within a existing shell.

1015-harquitectes-equipament-civic-cristalerias-planell-1

Aspects of its planning will seem familiar by now,

1015-harquitectes-equipament-civic-cristalerias-planell-21

but the integration of an environmental strategy is something new. We don’t¬†see diagrams like these next as often as we used to but it’s not because what they indicate has become¬†accepted best practice.

1015-harquitectes-equipament-civic-cristalerias-planell-291015-harquitectes-equipament-civic-cristalerias-planell-28

1015-harquitectes-equipament-civic-cristalerias-planell-26

6. Economy of resources 2

An ability to see and maximise the potential of existing structures is evident in the above project and also in this one for the refurbishment and extension of a school.

906-harquitectes-escola-sabadell-29

906-harquitectes-escola-sabadell-1

The approach to the extension you will recognise from Lacaton & Vassal’s Transformation de la Tour Bois le Pr√™tre. The providing of additional space¬†is what extensions are about.

7. Economy of resources 3

H Arquitectes seem to have no preferred material but whatever they use seems to be like it was always meant to be used that way. Here’s¬†Casa Escala again. It’s forthrightness is shocking. It is what it is ‚Ästa column and slab structure¬†such as you’re likely to see dotted around the Iberian Peninsula in varying stages of construction. ¬†

8. An approach for our times

In 2012 I wrote about The New Architecture of Austerity. Austerity hasn’t gone away. H Arquitectes have mainly designed and built houses but notable amongst their other projects are two extensions to schools and a municipal gymnasium. Municipal facilities, even in Barcelona, have been hard hit by ailing economies and H Arquuitects have been able to devise a credible approach to how to design and build to maximise¬†limited budgets. This approach has elements of environmental sustainability but stronger still is how it seems to have arisen from a desire to be economically viable and with no loss of humaneness.

9. Neither art nor artifice

It’s difficult to even write the word ‘materiality’ without sounding pretentious but I can’t think of a better way to describe this attitude where materials are allowed to be what they are. This¬†is not a¬†Barcelona Pavilion display of expensive and¬†rare¬†materials veiled as an aesthetic. Often, an abundance of different materials is allowed to coexist, each doing what they do.¬†¬†This attitude extends to fittings such as the light fitting and conduits.

906-harquitectes-escola-sabadell-26

906-harquitectes-escola-sabadell-23

906-harquitectes-escola-sabadell-19

The same sensibility can be seen in Casa Sant Cugat del Vales.

1101-harquitectes-casa-sant-cugat-11

or the fittings in Casa Parets del Valles 

804-harquitectes-casa-barcelona-09

or the cladding fixing¬†on¬†Casa Vacarisses.¬†It’s the application of thought and care that transforms these simple things into objects of beauty.

205-harquitectes-casa-barcelona-11

As extension of this attitude is the use of trellised plants as an active building component, notably Casa Barcelona, but here at the Council Gymnasium for Barberà del Vallès

704-harquitectes-gimnas-barcelona-08

and again, the Student Housing for the University of Sant Cugat.

912-harquitectes-habitatges-universitaris-sant-cugat-01.jpg

We’re not unfamiliar with this kind of sensibility to materials and construction but it’s not¬†a contrived ad-hocness, a precious high-tech¬†statement, or a vapid¬†expressionism. Everything is the right material for what it has to do and is allowed to happen¬†naturally.

Plans however, can’t be just allowed to happen. Designing a plan to¬†make everything fit a volume without¬†excess space means an excess of materials and budget won’t¬†needed¬†to enclose that space. Not wasting space means no space not¬†working¬†to make the building perform better. The entrance courtyard to Centre Civic Cristalerias Planell¬†isn’t¬†rentable space but is entrance, lightwell and environmental strategy all in one.

 

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

What’s not to like?¬†

Very very little. Out of 23 projects, the only thing I’m still wondering about¬†are¬†the intersecting walls¬†in the¬†Centre Civic Cristalerias Planell project. With Casa Gualba the walls were intersected in the simplest possible way and, if it represented anything, it represented nothing more than that. Upscaling the idea still¬†says the same simple thing but, because the bricks aren’t proportionally bigger,¬†is no longer that simple to build. An authentic¬†simplicity is¬†still there but harder to find. At the same time, the¬†representation of simplicity becomes¬†easier to see. I can’t tell if it’s more important or not and I’m¬†disturbed it’s such a close call.

The other thing I’m still pondering are¬†the ornamental gestures on their¬†Granollers Housing.

137-harquitectes-habitatges-granollers-15.jpg

Since¬†Architecture Misfit #20: Togo Murano¬†I’ve been more accepting towards aesthetic gestures that resist rationalization. HA’s¬†website text says

Besides, print inscriptions and ornamental recessed caps remind us of a tattoo that reinforces the perception of skin and gives a personal and human touch to the building.

This is true but though tattoos¬†may draw attention to the skin¬†they¬†rarely¬†improve it¬†or our appreciation of it. Having said that, the two most successful¬†tattoos I’ve ever seen were¬†in Barcelona so maybe I need to¬†get out more.

But¬†where’s the “Design”?

It’s all design. Nothing is allowed to happen by chance. I’m¬†reminded of Shakespeare’s sonnets, each one different and posing¬†a new problem to be solved as effortlessly as possible ‚Äď or at least they do if you agree with Helen Vendler’s formalist analysis of¬†them.¬†People who disagree (and many do) say ‘even if all that is true, the art of¬†Shakespeare’s sonnets¬†is so much more’. The same question now needs to be asked of H Arquitectes.

Heading¬†this blog for a while now has been the new misfits’ tagline without art or artifice.

  1. Both of these are very much present in the buildings of H Arquitectes but
  2. the architectural design process can’t (or rather, shouldn’t) begin with the¬†intent to display artifice or create art¬†‚Äď it should begin with a problem to be solved.
  3. Solving that problem requires the application of skill and intelligence and this means  that artifice is present from beginning to end.

So much of what’s presented to us as art and architecture these days is flawed from the beginning because it attempts to forcibly create art and directs¬†all¬†artifice to that one end. (The absurd but all too real extreme is that for something to be art, the only artifice thats needed is for its creator to say it is art.¬†We’ve come to accept this and don’t ask too many questions out of fear we’re being had.)

H Arquitectes’ artifice is mostly invisible and the results apparently effortless. This allows the classic Formalist position¬†whereby¬†Art is admitted as a concept¬†to¬†explain artifice we don’t¬†register¬†or, even if we did, are happy to not¬†comprehend. There’s nothing wrong with this and it’s not a contradiction.¬†An identity as¬†Art¬†at the end of a process¬†simply means the artifice is¬†perfect. This is how I view H Arquitectes’ buildings.

Finally, we come to my tenth point and that was probably the most important one anyway,

10. The joy of making things

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

H Arquitectes!

H-ARQUITECTES-Team

for letting things happen,
for caring about how to make things,
for using budget and environment as drivers,
for being sensitive to materials whatever their cost or quality,
for showing us how a humane architecture can be derived from these but,
most of all, for giving us hope this current dark age of architecture might finally be ending

misfits’ salutes you!

 

 

Architecture Misfit #21: śĚĎťáéŤó§Śźĺ

Some of¬†TŇćgŇć Murano’s work is incomprehensible and indescribably beautiful at the same time. It makes me want to believe in architecture as Art. My personal cynic tells me¬†that positing the existence of a higher logic is primitive human response to¬†anything resisting¬†easy comprehension, but still …

603ab12428bde878d8469860d05599e8

Some of Togo Murano’s designs resist not only easy comprehension but sustained rational¬†analysis as well. In the end, no framework for understanding presents itself other than one person’s¬†will for it to be like that. I’m used to saying that in a bad way for things I dislike, but I’m not accustomed¬†to saying it for things I’m drawn to.

Murano’s aesthetic sensibility is connected his¬†mastery of Japanese architecture’s sukiya style. We can think of sukiya as classical Japanese architecture that’s been loosened-up to admit idiosyncrasies.

ś°āťõĘŚģģ¬†‚Äď the very same¬†Katsura Imperial Villa¬†that impressed both Wright and Gropius alike is¬†of this style. Example. Look at the path in the image above. There’s a bit of fancy stonework and some¬†irregular stones laid irregularly but also¬†three square ones and an oddly shaped fourth one with corners touching in checkerboard fashion. What’s going on? I have no idea. There is no explanation other than somebody decided to make it like that. And it’s fine.

Think of sukiya¬†as a Japanese Louis XVI but one for which¬†Louis XV never happened. It’s not about the forms but the attitude to them. It’s the¬†combination of¬†refinement and simplicity that Pawson’s and Ando’s minimalism lacks and it‘s this very combination that places it very squarely in the realm of art. Sukiya¬†allows¬†the superfluous and the flawed if they¬†heighten awareness of the overall¬†perfection¬†‚Äď it’s the geisha’s single hair contrivedly yet perfectly out of place. It’s a hard act to pull off but Murano does, mostly.

Murano’s buildings are about buildings but his most valuable¬†contribution is this unique¬†combination of art and artifice. As such, it would¬†normally preclude him being considered an architecture misfit but what makes him¬†one¬†is his attitude. I will¬†set out my evidence.

1) There is no Murano style.

He had no theory or ideology but he wrote two books, the first in 1919. Its title,¬†śßėŚľŹ„Āģšłä„Āę„Āā„āƬ†[Yoshiki no Ueniare, Staying Above Style], says it all.¬†775¬†There are about 300 built Murano projects and few are alike. His career spanned seven decades but his approach never differed even as¬†his¬†stylistic and technical resources increased.¬†He embraced new materials and new technologies but never as one-liner showpieces as a Jean Nouvel or a Herzog de Meuron might. In place of consistent style or materials, Murano relied on his sense for what he felt the brief demanded.¬†He wasn’t afraid to design a traditional building if the brief suggested it. Here’s his New Osaka Kabuki Theatre from 1958. He didn’t see why a¬†traditional art form needed a modernistic building.

3280308459_924bc86181

Murano did not treat every commission as an opportunity to further his personal brand. Hero.

2) Murano believed buildings should be true to the present, not the past or a future. 

His first building is from 1918 but one of his more famous early ones is the 1936 SOGO Department Store in Osaka.

In 1936 Japan as well as most other places in the world, this building was as modern as modern could be. The logic is easy to see: department stores were a new building typology and suggested this style that represented newness.

3) Murano admitted the role of the client. 

Murano said the client was responsible for designing 98% of a project and that the¬†2% remaining was sufficient to make any building into one of his. This is interesting. What¬†if this¬†were¬†true of¬†all architects?¬†If we¬†assume that, then the situation we have today is one where that 2% gets presented and evaluated as¬†100% of the building and, what’s more, that 2% gets¬†designed before the other 98%. Our idea of architecture as art has little in common with Murano’s.¬†¬†

4) Murano had no craving for international fame

Until the end of his life Murano¬†made it a point to take time off every year and travel to¬†look at buildings. Despite this interest in what others were doing, he did not court international media attention like the boyband Metabolists. He wasn’t interested in visionary proposals,¬†had no wish¬†to design everything everywhere, and no appetite for¬†being internationally understood or appreciated. He did not expand into global masterplanning like Tange, or hawk his back catalogue¬†around the Middle East like Isozaki is still doing.

Prior to the opening of Expo ’70, Kenzo Tange was asked for His Thoughts and said something like “the only pavilion that really angers me is the Matsushita Pavilion” [that’s it in the middle]. He continued, “Tradition is like a millstone around our necks. Our job is to smash it and reassemble it …” etc. etc. In 1969 I admired this but, in retrospect, he sounds like someone who’s used to being listened to… who speaks in quotes ‚Äď which, before soundbites, was all there was.

expo70_19

There are no Murano buildings outside Japan.¬†It was never Murano’s intention to 1) update Japanese architecture, 2)¬†create a modernist Japanese architecture, or 3)¬†synthesise east and west or propagate any of those¬†usual narratives that play so well in the west. For not putting himself in a position for us to discover him as one of us, Murano is¬†little known or appreciated outside Japan.¬†

5) Murano never went along with theories of the moment

Murano believed buildings should be of the present but his view of the present involves more than whatever new technologies or ideologies were around at the time. Despite living through both the birth and death of modernism, Murano never went in for that modern affectation of inside and outside being one and the same thing called space. The contrast between the insides and the outsides of his buildings is striking.

Nissei Theatre, Tokyo, 1963

Notice how there is no attempt to design or otherwise hide light fittings, air conditioning outlets, lighting rigs and all¬†the other necessities? See how ventilation outlets have their own pattern superimposed in a pattern and onto another pattern? It’s exciting and not overcooked. Sukiya’s acceptance of the artful anomaly makes it a very useful¬†aesthetic for¬†accommodating different logics. It’s the exact opposite of the total design. Wright and Gropius may have thought sukiya important and reference-worthy, but they never understood it.

dam-images-travel-2015-tokyo-tokyo-japan-05-new

And yes, that’s inlaid mother-of-pearl on the ceiling. A difference between an inside and an outside is perhaps understandable in a theatre but the outside of Nissei Theater doesn’t suggest a theatre within. The lobby is something else¬†again.

nissei25

Murano’s refusal to see the¬†inside and outside as the same thing is eminently sensible. If you want to be¬†outside you go outside and sit on a seat and enjoy being outside. And when you’re tired of that you go inside¬†or ‚Äď if you wish ‚Äď gaze¬†outside through a window.

Hakone Prince Hotel, Hakone, Japan 1978

The weather on Lake Ashinoko is very changeable and nearly always chillier than you expected when you boarded that train from Shinjuku.

The message is: When the weather is fine, enjoy the weather being fine. The question is: why should there be a¬†distinction between inside and outside? Nobody has ever¬†told us why that should be a good thing.¬†OK but¬†what’s with the extruded¬†volutes? The petalled roof? The steel columns supporting inverted brick buttresses? We fixate on the outdoor furniture¬†because it’s the only thing we can form¬†an opinion on. The rest is unknowable and disturbing.

Geppa-ro

One lingering question is where did our fixation on this inside-outside merge¬†thing come from? IT’S NOT JAPAN.¬†Sure, the walls can slide away and all that but you’re still on the¬†inside looking out. Fresh air and light enter as physical sensations. Space stays firmly put.

Hakone Jumokuen Rest Pavilion, Kanazawa Prefecture, Japan 1971

The relaxation that comes from inside being inside and outside being outside is evident in this pavilion amidst¬†a very walkable forest. Stylistically, it’s what¬†you’d hope¬†to¬†encounter when you realise you’ve forgotten your umbrella or feel like a sit-down.

Inside is a different world. This is not some Thoreau cabin in the woods.

Untitled 4

6) Idiosyncrasy

I’ve mentioned the stone paving as an example of the idiosyncrasy¬†sukiya¬†admits and the lighting fixture above is another example. The branching lamp with its petalled shades is Calder and cherry blossom combined, and meant to be appreciated for what it is.¬†Murano paid special attention to the design of light fittings. Here’s two¬†more examples from the Hakone Prince Hotel.

Those horses have been disturbing me for decades but I can’t think of anything else I would rather see tied together garlanding that ceiling.

Of all the Murano buildings I know, I thought Takarazuka Catholic Church perhaps my least favourite for the wilful expressiveness of its shape

until I saw this photograph.

homekara_200712L

I mentioned the geisha’s one hair out of place drawing attention to the perfection. Here’s Murano’s Japan Lutheran Theological Seminary from 1969.¬†Check that detail.

Is it unnecessary? Is it borderline kitsch? I don’t know, but other architects’ attempts are heavy-handed by comparison.

1241232305_dbcac36898_b.jpg

I do believe such a thing as a Japanese design sensibility exists and I do believe it derives from sukiya sensibility. You can see it¬†here in this image of the hydraulic¬†dampers on¬†the roof of Tange’s 1964 Tokyo Olympic Stadium Complex.

IMG_0288

We can see¬†the red as proto‚ÄďHigh Tech but we do¬†Tange an injustice and overrate the High-Tecchies when we do. The logic behind¬†the shape of¬†that hole is inaccessible to us. It’s unresolvable yet¬†perfect and, as such, expressive of nothing else but someone’s desire to make it so. Whilst never forgetting¬†that Japan is also the country that gave us Hello Kitty, for something to be¬†expressive of nothing else but someone’s desire to make it so¬†is a very sophisticated and dangerous aesthetic concept. I wouldn’t trust it in the hands of any architect who wasn’t¬†Tange or Shinohara or¬†Murano and, even then, not all the time.

Even though he had no personal style or styles,¬†Murano’s attitude towards design was¬†the most consistent of the three. He let Modernism and Post-Modernism run their courses without becoming enamoured of structural or construction expressionism yet, on the other hand, some of his buildings are about just¬†that. This is Tanimura Art Museum of 1983.

no1_04

It’s easy to appreciate the structural and construction logic of posts and beams but Murano coaxes a moody materiality out of¬†sprayed concrete.¬†He had an instinct for materials and how to use them.¬†

1946: World Peace Memorial Temple

Here, 37 years earlier, we have structure expressed yet unexpressive, and materials with an immaterial materiality. I’ll try to¬†explain.

The brick relief pattern I understand a little. In the world of graphic and textile design it’s called a step-and-repeat when¬†identical motifs¬†form a larger pattern and, with this building, a greater pattern of diagonals¬†floats across¬†the facade and the¬†concrete frame. What I find difficult to¬†imagine is 1) conceiving it¬†and 2) detailing it. The brick¬†relief and the¬†windows are¬†the main¬†external decorative inputs and both have¬†no meaning other than somebody wanted them to be that way. And what about the way the mortar is laid? What would somebody do that? We must not forget we are in Japan ‚Äď this is not sloppiness. Someone, Murano, has decided this is how the joints must be formed. Why? I can only hazard a guess and say it’s as if the building bleeds, or perhaps weeps. It’s only my guess. Murano obviously made a decision to have the bricks laid with this kind of joint (which looks careless but can’t be easy to contrive) but what I admire about Murano is that he never made a point of saying why he wanted it this way. What I admire about the Japanese is that nobody ever asked.¬†As for what it all means as a whole, this building is in Hiroshima and its construction began within a¬†year of¬†August 6, 1946. That is meaning enough.

Hiroshima has no need for buildings laden with meaning, least of all¬†churchy ones with stained glass. By comparison, Tange’s 1955 Hiroshima Peace Memorial Museum¬†is a blank slate

tange-kenzo-hiroshmima-museum.jpg

and probably better for it as the international face of a national grief. People invest it¬†¬†with 100% of whatever¬†meaning they¬†want and completely on their terms. It’s¬†easy to like.¬†Murano’s¬†World Peace Memorial Cathedral is a more private affair. It’s a church for remembrance and make you remember it does.

8672874_world-peace-memorial-cathedral--togo-murano_t80a051ae

And there’s no doubt about what. It’s easier to focus on the dappled golden light rather than on that¬†intensely disturbing slash of gold mosaic displacing, distorting and disfiguring¬†the¬†icon in the apse.¬†The stability of those red and blue stained glass windows is¬†very comforting and life-affirming.¬†

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

This site¬†(in Japanese) has the most¬†complete list of works I could find. There are many buildings¬†I haven’t mentioned here but there is much more to discover. For example, Murano had a special gift for staircases.

Of Murano’s three hundred buildings, I selected the ones I did¬†because they best illustrated the things¬†I wanted to draw attention to but [confession time]¬†I’d never known until last week that he was also the architect of¬†the Industrial Bank of Japan¬†‚Äď a building I’ve admired for decades. This building¬†was¬†an existence I just accepted ‚Äď it never occurred to me someone might have designed it.¬†

Here’s an idea! We currently have a big problem¬†with media management and too¬†much information about too many buildings. This makes us unable to determine what is of any worth, let alone art. So how about we¬†have some standards, reset the bar high and narrow the field by only¬†considering buildings¬†that have an existence independent of their creator? If you need to know who designed it before you have an opinion about it, it’s not worth¬†knowing.

1974: Industrial Bank Of Japan (now Mizuho Headquarters)

All mechanical spaces are in that portion cantilevered over a reflecting pool (now replaced by planting). The pool, which you can see here,

126166082645416106888

originally had a whirlpool in the far corner. It was eerily and profoundly impressive. It had depth. The entire building has gravity. See how the building meets the ground with that fillet of polished granite?

The sidewalk¬†was paved in the same stone, unpolished. It’s an astounding level of thought and care. I’m as impressed now as I was in 1974.

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

Togo Murano

śĚĎťáéŤó§Śźĺ
1891 ‚Äď 1984

for solving the same problem three hundred times

misfits’ salutes you!

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

14676921793_2167219aa7_o

 

Architecture Misfit #20: Edward T. Potter

Another New York post. We can call this one Serious New York, or perhaps New York in the Time of Cholera. The link between poor housing and diseases such as yellow fever and cholera was established in 1820 by a Dr. Richard Pennell but squalid conditions in tenements continued to result in major outbreaks in 1822, 1823, 1832 and 1834 and even larger ones in 1849 and 1866. Gotham Court was a target for early housing reforms. It was nasty.

Untitled

Untitled 2

Gotham Court

[I have Richard Plunz’s excellent book¬†A History of Housing in New York City¬†to thank for most¬†of the information and all the plans in¬†this post.]

61VqUAswOML._SX258_BO1,204,203,200_

Only around 1850 did there even begin to be a desire to improve things.

1850 reforms

The first results were the Workingmens’ Buildings of 1865. They featured¬†a ventilated access corridor and privy [a room or building with one or more toilets].

Workingmens Buildings.jpeg

It still had windowless rooms ‚Äď a situation that was to become more common until the first tenement housing legislation of 1879.

Railroad Flat

Lack of legislation led to developments such as The Rookery in¬†1865. It had three parallel lines of development across five small lots ‚Äď a denser kind of nasty.

Rookery

Even so, it wasn’t uncommon elsewhere for rooms to have¬†windows facing walls a foot away.

Window

The first ‘improved’ tenements saw the addition of airshafts giving¬†the¬†appearance of the¬†opportunity of¬†ventilation to inner rooms. Note the diamond-shaped shaft in the example on the left.

air shaft

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

000038_291307c0kspk0eedj43w19

Edward Tuckerman Potter 
1831‚Äď1904

In 1874 Edward Tuckerman Potter completed his house for Mark Twain that he is best remembered for, mostly because it was for Mark Twain rather than its Victorian Gothic design that, although lovely, was unremarkable for the time.

twain-house-at-sunset.jpg

Mark Twain House was the exception for Potter was essentially a church architect. Sixty-six of his seventy-nine known buildings are churches.

The most famous is Nott Memorial Hall at the Union College campus in Schenectady NY (1858-1879).

NottMemorialPano-2

Nott Hall¬†and Mark Twain House are both National Historic Landmarks but many of Potter’s other buildings are on registers of historic buildings. Potter¬†was comfortable with the styles of the day and had the sense to restrain¬†his taste for Gothic and polychromy to suit¬†the budgets and sensibilities¬†of his¬†client parishes. He had a good¬†career and retired in 1877 at the age of 46.

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

In 1879 a new magazine called Plumbing and Sanitary Engineer ran a competition calling for the design of improved tenement housing. The competition brief was to provide better ventilation, sanitation and fireproofing yet at the same time provide sufficient accommodation to make building the design economically viable as an investment. This was the winning entry by James E. Ware.

Dumbell Apartment

Ware’s proposal wasn’t particularly innovative but¬†it did imply that¬†the size of the airshafts could be doubled by building identical buildings adjacent. Other entries took¬†this as a premise. This next scheme by George Da Cunha was designed to be built in pairs with open galleries around an airshaft which for the first time seems like it could also function as a light well.

George Da Cuhna

It’s probably unfair to remember James E.¬†Ware only as the inventor of the ‘dumbell apartment’ for he did¬†submit another¬†scheme proposing an idea similar to Da Cunha’s but more elegantly solved. It placed ninth.

Ware ninth.jpeg

This next scheme by Robert G. Kennedy connects the lightwell to the street to make it into an alleyway. This increases the volume of air that can move, particularly if the proposal is built in pairs along and across the block.

Robert G. Kennedy

Nevertheless, the competition and¬†Ware’s winning entry came in for some well-deserved criticism.

Ware criticism

This must have stung, for Ware modified his winning entry to provide the internal room with a window. He would have known he was increasing the external surface area of the building and making it less profitable for developers.

Ware revision

What we can learn from this is that it took some timely criticism articulating the changing public mood to remind developers and their architects of their duty to society. Enough was enough. Over the next several years, Potter was to give some thought to how to improve tenement housing. This is what he came up with.

Potter 1.jpg

  • His¬†most radical suggestion was to increase the lot to¬†37.5′ from¬†the 25′ that was the norm. To compensate, there are now six apartments¬†rather than Ware’s¬†four on a¬†25′ lot, producing no net change in density.
  • Two of those apartments are now large four-room apartments while the others remain¬†three-room. This is a net space gain.
  • As in the Kennedy proposal, the light wells are now access alleyways with space for planting on the sides of the paths. Integrating¬†the lightwell and¬†access route¬†means no internal area needed to be constructed to access stairwells. It also means all apartments can be accessed from stair landings.
  • All rooms have windows.
  • All apartments have not only ventilation but cross ventilation.
  • Walls angle¬†windows towards the street increasing views and lessening angles of overlooking across¬†the alleyway.
  • Stairwells are naturally lit and ventilated.

This is what it looked like. The year was 1888.

potter-2

  • The building was made completely made of masonry, steel, and glass.
  • The stairs were roofed in glass.
  • Some windows had translucent louvres for privacy and others had sun shading devices.
  • Roofs had¬†gardens [!]
  • Each apartment would receive one hour of direct sunlight daily. This would be determined¬†by the width of the alleyways and must be what led¬†Potter to propose increasing the lot width. It would also be why the building tapers towards¬†the front.
  • Today, we would comprehend¬†this building as ‘functionalist’ in terms of style but functionalism hadn’t been invented yet as a way to¬†design buildings,¬†let alone¬†labelled a style. (The perforated balustrades are intriguing, using less material to make void into ornament as they do.)

Ensuring adequate sunlight and ventilation was one of Potter’s preoccupations but not only¬†for tenement buildings.¬†This next image is from a¬†study, published in 1887, showing how to achieve maximum light and ventilation for¬†the new¬†high-rise buildings. These principles first appeared¬†in¬†New York City building legislation in¬†1916, more fully in 1929.

Potter 3

In¬†1897 Potter¬†attended the International Congress on Low Cost Housing in Brussels and presented his designs and¬†the model pictured¬†above. It’d be wonderful to know who else attended this Congress. J P Oud probably didn’t as he was seven and the Swiss boy who was to become Le Corbusier was ten. But if, for example,¬†Henry van de Velde¬†attended the Congress prior to his move¬†to Weimar two years later, that would link Potter with European Functionalism and¬†the European Modernism that was to be imported back to the United States thirty¬†years later minus European ideas of social utility, let alone the original American ones.

‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ ‚ÄĘ

Edward Tuckerman Potter died on December 21, 1904. An obituary in The American Architect reports that Potter, ‘possessing independent means,’ was able to retire early and devote himself to ‘travel, the study of music and philanthropy.’¬†Potter worked in his later years to devise ‚Äúways and means of securing to tenement houses and their inmates not only economical and convenient planning, but the best of natural ventilation and lighting.¬†In all tenement and prison reform movements he took an active part, so that, quite apart from his architectural work, he led a satisfying and useful life, to which further grace was added by his musical successes as a composer of sacred and even operatic scores.‚ÄĚ

We don’t know what Potter thought of his church buildings but his work to improve¬†tenements showed he viewed¬†philanthropy and social utility¬†as something separate from architecture. It’s still common to think so, even today. By¬†applauding anything we can call ‘humanitarian’ if it happens in some other country, we like to think architecture and humanitarianism are merging. They’re not. The two will¬†remain firmly¬†separate until we develop¬†a¬†concept of what a humanitarian architecture is in our own country. Until that time, we’re just outsourcing gratification as our capacity to¬†produce¬†it hollows out.

Unlike us, Potter’s concerns were not separated across countries¬†but across¬†time. He¬†had to retire from architecture before turning his attention to humanitarian¬†concerns such as improving tenement housing. But at least he did! His interest may have been humanitarian¬†rather than architectural but, once he put his architectural mind to it, he solved the problem¬†quickly and he solved it well. He’s not a hero. He merely freed himself from the professional conventions and stylizations¬†of his time to do¬†what he felt he had to do. As¬†most architects devote much of their energies to aligning themselves with the conventions and stylizations of their times, perhaps he’s a hero after all. Either way,

potter-edward-tuckerman.png

Edward Tuckerman Potter 
1831‚Äď1904

for becoming an architect after having left architecture,

misfits’ salutes you!