Skip to content

Category: REVIEWS


Categories:

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Vol.1 Chaps. 3.1~3.3

Post date:
Author:

This is la veuve Cliquot. This past week saw another grande dame, Dame Zaha Hadid named Veuve Cliquot Businesswoman of the Year. To receive this award one has to meet the following criteria. Entrepreneurship: founder / leader and driving force of a business through pioneering approach, business acument, dynamism, audacity, innovation, tenacity Financial Success: sustained profitable business growth […]

Categories:

The Red Igloo vs. The Autopoiesis of Architecture

The Red Igloo vs. The Autopoiesis of Architecture
Post date:
Author:
Number of comments: 3 comments

This post is a mashup of my 2010 architecture fable The Red Igloo, and thoughts from Patrik Schumacher’s The Autopoiesis of Architecture. Both purport to convey some kind of truth about architecture. * * * Once upon a time all Inuit people made igloos the same way. Vernacular building relies on tradition, on well proven solutions taken for granted. […]

Categories:

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Volume 1 Chapter 2.5 – The Necessity of Demarcation

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Volume 1 Chapter 2.5 – The Necessity of Demarcation
Post date:
Author:

THESIS 9: Any attempt to integrate architecture and art, or architecture and science/engineering, in a unified discourse (autopoiesis) is reactionary and bound to fail. Even though Luhmann, the guy who put all these ideas in the author’s head, said that architecture existed within the great social system of art, in this sub-chapter (p148), the author […]

Categories:

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Vol.1 Chapter 2.4 – Architectural Research

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Vol.1 Chapter 2.4 – Architectural Research
Post date:
Author:
Number of comments: no comments

This book is taking a while to get going. I’m somewhere between a third and half-way through volume 1 and have concluded that taking it sub-chapter by sub-chapter is probably the best way to do it. Fortunately, sub-chapter 2.4 is a particularly rich one. It may even be the turning point of the entire book. THESIS […]

Categories:

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Vol.1 Chap. 2.3 – Avant-garde vs. Mainstream

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Vol.1 Chap.  2.3 – Avant-garde vs. Mainstream
Post date:
Author:
Number of comments: 3 comments

Increasingly, I’m beginning to think that what the book describes is probably an accurate description of the world of architecture the author sees. In this chapter, for the first time, I had the distinct impression that the author really believes what he is writing. In a previous Book Club post, I mentioned my doubts about the validity […]

Categories:

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Vol.1 Chap. 2 – The Historical Emergence of Architecture (1/2)

Post date:
Author:
Number of comments: 5 comments

The story so far … THE AUTHOR, IN AN ATTEMPT TO FIT ARCHITECTURE INTO LUHMANN’S THEORY OF SOCIAL STRUCTURES, HAS RESTRICTED HIS  DEFINITION OF ARCHITECTURE TO THOSE BUILDINGS THEORISTS TALK ABOUT OR DEEM WORTH TALKING ABOUT. THE AUTHOR MAY YET SUCCEED. BUT WHAT IS HIS REAL PLAN? WHY DOES HE WANT TO DO THIS? AND AT WHAT COST? There’s some truth in it though. For example, nobody cared […]

Categories:

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Vol.1 Chap.1: Architectural Theory

Post date:
Author:
Number of comments: 3 comments

Continuing these meditations upon the reading of The Autopoiesis of Architecture, the inspiration for this post was Chapter 1: Architectural Theory. The Introduction mentioned that the phenomenon of architecture can be analysed as an autonomous network (and autopoietic system) of communications along the lines of that proposed by Niklaus Luhmann for social systems.  Let’s not […]

Categories:

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Vol. 1 – Preface, Introduction

The Autopoiesis of Architecture: Vol. 1 – Preface, Introduction
Post date:
Author:
Number of comments: 3 comments

Welcome to Book Club! Please join me as I blog thoughts on volume one of Patrik Schumacher’s “magnum opus” as I read it. I’ve heard its 438 pages contain only 18 pictures – as if that’s a good thing! – so I already expect it’s going to be fairly hard going. This won’t be a […]